What's the difference between an HSA, FSA, and HRA?
All three are tax-advantaged accounts that pay healthcare expenses with pre-tax dollars, but they differ on ownership, eligibility, and rollover.
- HSA (Health Savings Account): employee-owned, requires enrollment in an HSA-qualified high-deductible health plan (HDHP), money rolls over year-to-year indefinitely, can be invested, portable when you change jobs, and triple-tax-advantaged (pre-tax contribution, tax-free growth, tax-free withdrawal for qualified medical). The most flexible of the three.
- FSA (Flexible Spending Account): employer-sponsored, no HDHP requirement, lower annual contribution cap, use-it-or-lose-it within the plan year (some plans allow a small carryover or grace period), not portable when you change jobs. Common as a payroll-deduction option for predictable medical spend.
- HRA (Health Reimbursement Arrangement): employer-funded only (employees don't contribute), reimburses qualified medical expenses up to a limit set by the employer, employer controls the rules (rollover, eligible expenses, what counts), not portable. Increasingly used in ICHRA form (Individual Coverage HRA) where employers fund employee purchase of individual marketplace plans.
For employees, HSA + HDHP is usually the most powerful combination if your medical spend is moderate and your cash flow can handle the high deductible. FSA is better for predictable, plannable spending. HRAs are entirely up to your employer's plan design.
- Category
- Personal Insurance
- Audience
- Pre-purchase guidance
- Topic
- Personal Insurance
Related FAQs
Are LTC premiums tax-deductible?
Federal: yes, as itemized medical expenses, subject to age-based limits that increase in steps every decade of age (current figures published annually by the IRS). The deduction phases in based on whether your total medical expenses exceed a percentage of AGI. NY allows a state income tax credit equal to a portion of LTC premiums paid (subject to caps). Self-employed individuals can deduct LTC premiums above-the-line up to the federal age-based limits. Confirm current dollar limits with a tax advisor…
Read answerAre NY plans different from plans elsewhere?
Yes, in two ways beyond community rating. (1) **NY mandated benefits** require coverage for things federal ACA doesn't mandate: infertility and IVF on most plans, autism spectrum disorder treatment including ABA therapy, broader contraception coverage, telehealth parity, and stricter mental health parity enforcement. (2) **Provider networks** in NY are heavily concentrated around the major hospital systems (NYC: NewYork-Presbyterian, Mount Sinai, NYU, Northwell, Montefiore; upstate: each region has 2–3 dominant systems) — picking a plan is functionally picking a hospital network.…
Read answerCan I see specific doctors / hospitals on the plan I'm considering?
This is the most important question and the most-overlooked one at enrollment. Marketplace plan summaries don't tell you network depth. The right move: get the list of every provider you currently see (PCP, specialists, dentist, mental health), call each one, ask "do you take [Plan Name from Carrier X for the current plan year]?" — and confirm the *specific plan*, not the carrier. Carriers offer many plans on different networks (e.g., HMO, EPO, PPO, narrow network) and a doctor accepting…
Read answerDo I need a medical exam?
For most term policies above $500K, yes — a paramedical exam (height, weight, blood pressure, blood draw, urine sample) at home or in an office. **No-exam (simplified or accelerated) underwriting** is increasingly available for healthy applicants under age 50–55 buying $500K–$2M of term, often with an answer in 1–7 days. **Guaranteed-issue** policies (no health questions, no exam) exist for older applicants but cap face value at $25K–$50K and are expensive per dollar of coverage. We pre-screen the underwriting category at…
Read answerDoesn't Medicare cover long-term care?
No, and this is the single most-misunderstood point in retirement planning. Medicare covers up to 100 days of **skilled nursing care** following a qualifying hospital stay (with cost-sharing after day 20). It does **not** cover custodial care — the day-in-day-out help with ADLs that constitutes the vast majority of long-term care needs. Medicaid covers long-term care, but only after you've spent down most of your assets. This is why people who want to control where and how they receive care,…
Read answer
STILL HAVE QUESTIONS?
We answer the same business day.
If yours isn't covered here, schedule a consultation and we'll get you a clear answer.